Justin Brookman's Avatar

Justin Brookman

@justinbrookman

tech policy for Consumer Reports

3,020
Followers
308
Following
56
Posts
20.06.2023
Joined
Posts Following

Latest posts by Justin Brookman @justinbrookman

Preview
Consumer Reports calls on the FTC and state attorneys general to take action against Meta for its failure to mitigate harmful scam advertisements - CR Advocacy Washington, DC – Consumer Reports is calling on the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and state attorneys general across the country to take enforcement action against…

“Meta is one of the largest publishers in the world and has a responsibility to protect its users from scams, yet it continually chooses to prioritize profits instead of protecting its users,” said Justin Brookman, director of tech policy at CR.

18.11.2025 15:30 👍 12 🔁 7 💬 0 📌 1
Lucas Duplan in a white blazer and Richard Branson in a leather jacket lighting fake money on fire with a lighter and smiling at the camera

Lucas Duplan in a white blazer and Richard Branson in a leather jacket lighting fake money on fire with a lighter and smiling at the camera

a DMCA take down request filed by Lucas Andrew Duplan to Google that reads: 

This article/image features a unique moment with Richard Branson and me in a private setting, showcasing a highly distinctive interaction involving burning banknotes and demonstrating new technology, reflecting a rare and specialized concept. As the copyright owner, I assert that this content is both original and of significant personal and commercial value. Its unauthorized use by third parties is without my permission and constitutes a clear violation of copyright law and misuse of protected intellectual property. Given the exclusive and recognizable nature of this image, it is imperative for Google to remove it promptly from search results to prevent further infringement, as there is no valid basis for further public dissemination without explicit permission. Additionally, there is little commercial value as the article is almost 10 years old. Thank you.

a DMCA take down request filed by Lucas Andrew Duplan to Google that reads: This article/image features a unique moment with Richard Branson and me in a private setting, showcasing a highly distinctive interaction involving burning banknotes and demonstrating new technology, reflecting a rare and specialized concept. As the copyright owner, I assert that this content is both original and of significant personal and commercial value. Its unauthorized use by third parties is without my permission and constitutes a clear violation of copyright law and misuse of protected intellectual property. Given the exclusive and recognizable nature of this image, it is imperative for Google to remove it promptly from search results to prevent further infringement, as there is no valid basis for further public dissemination without explicit permission. Additionally, there is little commercial value as the article is almost 10 years old. Thank you.

I wrote a story in 2014 about a digital payments startup called Clinkle. At the time, a source provided me with photo of Clinkle CEO Lucas Duplan burning (fake) money with Richard Branson. It became a metaphor after Clinkle crashed.

Now Duplan filed a DMCA takedown to get it removed from Google.

03.06.2025 17:03 👍 381 🔁 91 💬 14 📌 11

Whoever at the CA bar was responsible for this should be fired immediately.

23.04.2025 16:11 👍 842 🔁 203 💬 27 📌 21
Preview
French scientist denied US entry after officers find phone messages criticizing Trump France’s research minister said the scientist was traveling to Houston for a conference when his phone was searched France’s research minister said a French scientist was denied entry to the US this month after immigration officers at an airport searched…

French scientist denied US entry after officers find phone messages criticizing Trump

19.03.2025 22:03 👍 686 🔁 368 💬 89 📌 143

I have seen several people argue that Trump has the constitutional right to fire minority commissioners at will (dubious, but I get the argument).

Has anyone serious argued that firing Slaughter and Bedoya is good governance or will make the FTC more effective?

19.03.2025 15:45 👍 2 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0
Last Friday afternoon, I got my first message from Ryan Daniels, public affairs manager of strategic response at Meta. When I declined his invitation to talk by phone, he wrote back again: “I was wondering if the Washington Post was going to write a review about a book that’s coming out this upcoming week on Meta. Do you have a couple minutes to chat?”

So, I called. Daniels said, “We don’t have the book,” but the company had prepared “preliminary statements” about it. Although he didn’t share those with me, he wrote to me again on Saturday and again on Monday trying to get information about our review plans. (In my 27 years of reviewing and editing newspaper books sections, no company has ever done this with me.)

Last Friday afternoon, I got my first message from Ryan Daniels, public affairs manager of strategic response at Meta. When I declined his invitation to talk by phone, he wrote back again: “I was wondering if the Washington Post was going to write a review about a book that’s coming out this upcoming week on Meta. Do you have a couple minutes to chat?” So, I called. Daniels said, “We don’t have the book,” but the company had prepared “preliminary statements” about it. Although he didn’t share those with me, he wrote to me again on Saturday and again on Monday trying to get information about our review plans. (In my 27 years of reviewing and editing newspaper books sections, no company has ever done this with me.)

Yesterday, when I reached out to Daniels for a response from Meta, he wrote back: “Do you plan to write something about it, or are you just curious how we’re responding?” 

It’s always about controlling the narrative. But apparently, that’s not going so well. This morning, “Careless People” is No. 3 on Amazon. 

I know this is a long item, the longest I’ve ever written for the Book Club newsletter. But when one of the world’s most powerful media companies tries to snuff out a book — amid other alarming attacks on free speech in America like this — it’s time to pull out all the stops.

Yesterday, when I reached out to Daniels for a response from Meta, he wrote back: “Do you plan to write something about it, or are you just curious how we’re responding?” It’s always about controlling the narrative. But apparently, that’s not going so well. This morning, “Careless People” is No. 3 on Amazon. I know this is a long item, the longest I’ve ever written for the Book Club newsletter. But when one of the world’s most powerful media companies tries to snuff out a book — amid other alarming attacks on free speech in America like this — it’s time to pull out all the stops.

WaPo's Ron Charles, in his Book Club newsletter, on Meta's repeated questions about his plans to review Sarah Wynn-Williams's "Careless People":

"In my 27 years of reviewing and editing newspaper books sections, no company has ever done this with me."

14.03.2025 17:12 👍 2787 🔁 914 💬 92 📌 238

The CR's effect on DC is a five alarm fire.

By treating the DC as a federal agency & compelling the city to return to 2024 spending,

Congress is mandating that DC cut its budget--*its own tax dollars*--by almost 20%.

None of this $ will be refunded to the fed gov; it was never theirs.

12.03.2025 13:16 👍 189 🔁 87 💬 6 📌 14
Preview
Should Humane’s Asset Sale Orphan an IoT Device? - Innovation at Consumer Reports The Humane AI pin turns to e-waste, yet another example of the tech industry selling a connected device without any plans of keeping it functional long-term

After HP bought Humane AI's assets to salvage the failed company, it left consumers in the lurch. So @justinbrookman.bsky.social and I wrote about how the FTC should crack down on companies that avoid responsibility for their failed connected devices by structuring deals as asset sales.

27.02.2025 20:47 👍 14 🔁 3 💬 0 📌 0
Post image

Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin issued the following statement announcing that his office has sued General Motors and its subsidiary OnStar for deceiving Arkansans and selling data collected through OnStar to third parties, who then sold the data to insurance companies.

26.02.2025 17:09 👍 3 🔁 3 💬 1 📌 1
Preview
The EU AI Act is Coming to America The AI regulation onslaught

I thought FPF has done a thoughtful job trying to find common ground of AI regulatory issues. I've had my quibbles which is not unexpected given they are mostly industry funded. But they're now being attacked as leftists trying to import EU law to America?! www.hyperdimensional.co/p/the-eu-ai-...

25.02.2025 20:09 👍 2 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Preview
FPF Convenes Over 200 State Lawmakers in AI Policy Working Group Focused on 2025 Legislative Sessions In the lead-up to the 2025 legislative session, FPF is excited to convene the expanded Multistate AI Policymaker Working Group (MAP-WG)—a bipartisan coalition of over 200 state lawmakers from more tha...

WOW. The Future of Privacy Forum gets bullied into abandoning their role as convenor of state legislators discussing AI policy. fpf.org/blog/future-...

25.02.2025 20:04 👍 8 🔁 3 💬 1 📌 0
THIS MATTER having come before this Court on the verified Petition of the City of Clarksdale requesting a temporary restraining order or a hearing on a preliminary injunction and after review of the verified Petition and Attorney Certification, the Court finds that the Petition is
well taken. The injury in this case is defamation against public figures through actual malice in reckless disregard of the truth and interferes with their legitimate function to advocate for legislation they believe would help their municipality during this current legislative cycle. The
Respondents are well aware of the accusations against them as they have already received a draft of the verified Petition and further notice is not needed until such hearing. The Temporary
Restraining Order for Respondents to remove the article "EDITORIAL: SECRECY AND DECEPTION ERODE PUBLIC TRUST" from their online portals and make it inaccessible to the public is hereby granted. Petitioner shall post a bond in the amount of $100.00 as security for any damages that Defendant may incur should it be determined that this Temporary Restraining Order was wrongfully issued. This Court further orders that a hearing on the City of Clarksdale's request for a preliminary injunction is hereby set for February 27, 2025, at 9:30 am

THIS MATTER having come before this Court on the verified Petition of the City of Clarksdale requesting a temporary restraining order or a hearing on a preliminary injunction and after review of the verified Petition and Attorney Certification, the Court finds that the Petition is well taken. The injury in this case is defamation against public figures through actual malice in reckless disregard of the truth and interferes with their legitimate function to advocate for legislation they believe would help their municipality during this current legislative cycle. The Respondents are well aware of the accusations against them as they have already received a draft of the verified Petition and further notice is not needed until such hearing. The Temporary Restraining Order for Respondents to remove the article "EDITORIAL: SECRECY AND DECEPTION ERODE PUBLIC TRUST" from their online portals and make it inaccessible to the public is hereby granted. Petitioner shall post a bond in the amount of $100.00 as security for any damages that Defendant may incur should it be determined that this Temporary Restraining Order was wrongfully issued. This Court further orders that a hearing on the City of Clarksdale's request for a preliminary injunction is hereby set for February 27, 2025, at 9:30 am

(Conclusion of the court order.)

(Conclusion of the court order.)

Wow: City of Clarksdale, Mississippi got a court order yesterday directing a newspaper to delete an editorial criticizing city officials -- without a hearing. Here's the TRO issuing the prior restraint:

19.02.2025 15:04 👍 3900 🔁 1657 💬 242 📌 344

Without these employees, I doubt already approved ARPA-H projects will be seeing their grant funding anytime soon. These are ambitious, billion dollar projects to tackle disease and cancer. This amounts to theft of taxpayer dollars. Not to mention the loss of institutional knowledge. 🧪

14.02.2025 21:11 👍 90 🔁 36 💬 4 📌 3
Video thumbnail

absolutely wild. i went to youtube to watch a video and the autoplay ad was an AI fake of tom hanks spouting fake diabetes cures. google is making money off this???

13.02.2025 20:42 👍 1168 🔁 297 💬 76 📌 65

Newsom vetoed this bill last year after it had passed the legislature by wide margins. But given Apple's and Google's continued refusal to make these tools available to their user base, it's great to see this bill coming back.

13.02.2025 20:55 👍 13 🔁 3 💬 0 📌 0
California State Capitol building. CPPA sponsors crucial data protection bill. Icon of a bill. Introduced by Assemblymember Josh Lowenthal, the bill requires browsers and mobile operating systems to support opt-out preference signals. CPPA lock logo.

California State Capitol building. CPPA sponsors crucial data protection bill. Icon of a bill. Introduced by Assemblymember Josh Lowenthal, the bill requires browsers and mobile operating systems to support opt-out preference signals. CPPA lock logo.

@asmlowenthal.bsky.social has introduced AB 566, sponsored by the CPPA. It requires browsers and mobile operating systems to give users the tools to opt out of the sale or sharing of their personal info in one step with opt-out preference signals. Read more: cppa.ca.gov/announcement...

13.02.2025 19:45 👍 18 🔁 11 💬 3 📌 3

Clerked for Justice Scalia, member of the Federalist Society, picked by Trump administration last month

13.02.2025 19:45 👍 1419 🔁 381 💬 41 📌 13

Yes! I have it constantly stuck in my head though.

13.02.2025 15:27 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Preview
Fintechs Move to Defend CFPB Open Banking Rule as Agency Recedes A trade group representing financial technology companies is moving to defend the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s open banking rule against a lawsuit from big banks while the agency’s litigatio...

One of the many CFPB rules that it's not currently defending in court is the open banking rule, which allows people to easily move their money. The Bank Policy Institute sued to block it. CFPB is standing down.
So today, the Financial Technology Association—the fintech lobby—intervened in the suit.

12.02.2025 15:54 👍 55 🔁 25 💬 1 📌 1
Preview
Trump taps bank, Wall Street regulators for top posts The moves come as Trump and his allies push for a drastic makeover of the financial regulatory system.

Trump picked Jonathan McKernan, who resigned on Monday from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. board, to lead the consumer bureau, replacing Biden appointee Rohit Chopra, an aggressive regulator who he ousted last month. www.politico.com/news/2025/02...

12.02.2025 02:55 👍 1 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0

gritty has seized control of the federal government

10.02.2025 03:31 👍 7732 🔁 1267 💬 195 📌 261

It's important to keep emphasizing that what Musk proposes in this tweet is illegal. Congress created the CFPB, just as it created USAID, the DOE, etc. Neither the President nor a billionaire can dissolve them by fiat. Doing so is a violation of the law and the President's constitutional duties.

07.02.2025 22:47 👍 2740 🔁 715 💬 79 📌 23
Post image

Today is my birthday, AND the galleys for my book came. I am told that Barnes and Noble is having a sale and A Physical Education is 25% off thru tomorrow with code PREORDER25. Here we are sharing a tender moment www.barnesandnoble.com/w/a-physical...

07.02.2025 01:17 👍 1540 🔁 91 💬 83 📌 7
Post image

new insane tech job listing just dropped

06.02.2025 15:15 👍 735 🔁 151 💬 58 📌 95
Preview
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Is Being Told to Stop Its Work. 5 Ways That Could Impact Consumers Like You. - Consumer Reports The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is being told to stop its enforcement and litigation work and suspend all rulemaking. How the changes could impact consumers.

www.consumerreports.org/consumer-pro...

06.02.2025 17:42 👍 6 🔁 3 💬 1 📌 1

If you wanted no leaks you should have gone into Settings -> Security -> Configure privacy & security -> Privacy options -> Other -> Configure -> Media interface and clicked “Disallow.”

The Leak setting is on by default but we understand your privacy is important so we’ve made it easy to opt out

30.01.2025 22:07 👍 31715 🔁 5476 💬 827 📌 271

His manifesto/job application called out big tech companies, though primarily in terms of anti-conservative censorship. I don't recall anything about the prices consumers pay for goods and services. But it's just Day 5, he still has a chance to show he takes this issue seriously.

24.01.2025 17:46 👍 3 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0

Consumer are very concerned about prices right now, and this is the FTC's core mission!

If Ferguson is serious about addressing this issue, he should either reissue the previous RFIs or quickly propose some alternative approach to demonstrate this remains a priority for the agency.

24.01.2025 17:03 👍 5 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
Post image

FWIW, Ferguson says he pulled the FTC's inquiries into pricing because of timing/process objections, not necessarily substance.

However, absent any replacement initiative, this sends a message to the marketplace that pricing is less of a priority for the agency now. www.ftc.gov/system/files...

24.01.2025 16:59 👍 6 🔁 2 💬 2 📌 0