Dan Silverman's Avatar

Dan Silverman

@dmsilverman

Assistant Professor of Political Science at Carnegie Mellon Institute for Strategy & Technology (CMIST) Ohio State PhD. International Security, Political Psychology, Middle East Politics Opinions my own, don’t reflect employer, etc.

3,617
Followers
1,875
Following
3,507
Posts
21.08.2023
Joined
Posts Following

Latest posts by Dan Silverman @dmsilverman

The information environment matters.

And consensus truth is a public good we can build democratic institutions to facilitate and protect.

07.03.2026 04:23 👍 19 🔁 6 💬 0 📌 0

It would be a great public service if a credible organization who monitors the info environment in war -- Bellingcat? -- would put out a simple rating system for the accuracy and reliability of the biggest OSINT accounts on X so that members of the public (and even experts) knew the landscape

07.03.2026 04:28 👍 4 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

Why are you doing this to us

07.03.2026 03:43 👍 4 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

Have we ever started a war that has spread to and imperiled so many countries at once? Can‘t think of one

07.03.2026 02:21 👍 5 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

This was clear from the jump, but the Venezuela invasion going as smoothly as it did, from a pure operational perspective, is going to prove catastrophic in the long run.

06.03.2026 14:34 👍 5343 🔁 636 💬 210 📌 61

Yeah it’s not that hard to understand folks. It’s classic Pape/Dying to Win. (Perceived) foreign occupation —> terrorist/violent resistance

Thus, if swaths of people perceive the U.S. to be “occupied” by Israel, some small slice of them may attack things that they associate with Israel

07.03.2026 00:54 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

Bay of Pigs 2.0 or Mogadishu 2.0 are still the chief dangers here

And since the admin can’t win, and certainly won’t want to admit it lost, there’s a real risk they try something

07.03.2026 00:28 👍 4 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0

Honestly, I’d read that

07.03.2026 00:15 👍 2 🔁 0 💬 2 📌 0

"The wealthy Gulf states and their people had good reason to feel that they were detaching from the region’s problems... The human price of regional power politics was supposed to be paid by Syrians, Sudanese, Lebanese, and Yemenis—not by them."

06.03.2026 12:29 👍 55 🔁 28 💬 1 📌 1

Very fair. I think there is a logic perhaps -- they believe that narrative reigns and you can bend the narrative however you want. Honestly, that can work more than we in the "reality-based community" like to admit sometimes but in cases like this, per my post, I think it is easy to blow up

06.03.2026 20:17 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

Seems like a very easy narrative for Iran to puncture, all they have to do is launch any fresh attack and the press will cover it and the "unconditionally surrendered" claim will be dead?

06.03.2026 19:38 👍 2 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0

In the end, though, I still think there’s a pretty decent shot he wins both the primary and the general despite all of these legitimate concerns

06.03.2026 19:08 👍 0 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

I have to admit, I think I‘ve been more torn on Platner than most on here but this thread definitely raises some serious concerns about his story from both an honesty and an electability perspective

06.03.2026 19:06 👍 3 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0
Donald J. Trump C @realDonaldTrump
+
There will be no deal with Iran except UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER! After that, and the selection of a GREAT & ACCEPTABLE Leader(s), we, and many of our wonderful and very brave allies and partners, will work tirelessly to bring Iran back from the brink of destruction, making it economically bigger, better, and stronger than ever before. IRAN WILL HAVE A GREAT FUTURE. "MAKE IRAN GREAT AGAIN (MIGA!)." Thank you for your attention to this matter! President DONALD J. TRUMP

Donald J. Trump C @realDonaldTrump + There will be no deal with Iran except UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER! After that, and the selection of a GREAT & ACCEPTABLE Leader(s), we, and many of our wonderful and very brave allies and partners, will work tirelessly to bring Iran back from the brink of destruction, making it economically bigger, better, and stronger than ever before. IRAN WILL HAVE A GREAT FUTURE. "MAKE IRAN GREAT AGAIN (MIGA!)." Thank you for your attention to this matter! President DONALD J. TRUMP

Unconditional surrender without ground troops. Right.

06.03.2026 14:08 👍 1233 🔁 192 💬 159 📌 63

Seriously wouldn't be surprised if they started moving toward body doubles or lookalikes at this point

06.03.2026 15:41 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

Needless to say, this war is incredibly foolish for the U.S.

But it's crazy that, *if you were going to do it,* you didn't do it 1-2 months ago when the population was actually out in force doing the thing you want on Iran's streets

06.03.2026 15:18 👍 10 🔁 0 💬 0 📌 0

So you want the Iranian people, some 20k of which was just slaughtered, to do what -- mass outside a few govt buildings and try to take them over?

Will those buildings be bombed? Do you realize how easily they can be painted as foreign collaborators now and mowed down? What is it you're suggesting?

06.03.2026 15:11 👍 108 🔁 13 💬 1 📌 0
Post image

DropSite going with the Humane Nazis angle on submarine warfare

06.03.2026 14:10 👍 151 🔁 14 💬 18 📌 24

Anecdotal and I’m sure views were mixed throughout the region, but I do have to say I have Pakistani *Sunni* *establishment* mutuals on FB who were posting martyrhood type memes of Khamenei after his death

06.03.2026 04:22 👍 4 🔁 2 💬 0 📌 0

I want to see a Dem supercut ad of Trump 2.0 officials’ most damning remarks, weaving this in with

-Musk’s “mistakes will be made” re: DOGE
-Leavitt’s “his main focus is the ballroom”
-Maybe throw in a “you people can have a few less dolls”
-End with JD laughing and saying “politics should be fun!”

06.03.2026 04:12 👍 4 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
Post image

The last photo of third-grader Mikaeil Mirdoraghi, waving to his mom before he left for school. He was killed shortly after in the U.S./Israeli strike on a primary school in Minab.

05.03.2026 21:10 👍 2800 🔁 1174 💬 90 📌 92
Preview
Azerbaijan says four injured by Iranian drones, vows to retaliate Azerbaijan was preparing unspecified retaliatory measures on Thursday after it said four Iranian drones had crossed its border and injured four ‌people in the Nakhchivan exclave, raising concerns abou...

Update: Oy

06.03.2026 03:00 👍 5 🔁 3 💬 0 📌 0
'We don't see any reason to negotiate:
Araghchi
We have more comments from Iran's top diplomat.
In a live interview with NBC, Abbas Aragchi said Iran is "not asking for a ceasefire".
"We don't see any reason why we should negotiate with the US", he said.
"When we negotiated with them twice, every time, they attacked us in the middle of negotiations."
Araghchi also emphasised that Iran has not closed the Strait of Hormuz, saying "it is the ships and tankers" that have refused to cross the waterway.

'We don't see any reason to negotiate: Araghchi We have more comments from Iran's top diplomat. In a live interview with NBC, Abbas Aragchi said Iran is "not asking for a ceasefire". "We don't see any reason why we should negotiate with the US", he said. "When we negotiated with them twice, every time, they attacked us in the middle of negotiations." Araghchi also emphasised that Iran has not closed the Strait of Hormuz, saying "it is the ships and tankers" that have refused to cross the waterway.

Iranian Foreign Minister:

“We don’t see any reason to negotiate”

(aje.news/0avpno?updat...)

05.03.2026 18:01 👍 290 🔁 99 💬 13 📌 14
Post image

It’s a good point — “Track AIPAC” seems to sketchily lump JStreet and other softer sources in under their umbrella phrase “pro-Israel lobby and their mega donors” for candidates they don’t like, and exclude them for those they do

06.03.2026 02:44 👍 4 🔁 1 💬 0 📌 0
Nancy Youssef, ..guil @ X.com
@nancyayoussef
The preliminary Pentagon cost estimate of the war in Iran is $1 billion a day, a congressional official told me.
12:20 PM • 3/4/26 • 44K Views

Nancy Youssef, ..guil @ X.com @nancyayoussef The preliminary Pentagon cost estimate of the war in Iran is $1 billion a day, a congressional official told me. 12:20 PM • 3/4/26 • 44K Views

Preliminary Pentagon cost estimate of the war in Iran is $1 BILLION a day. So far.

04.03.2026 19:15 👍 1654 🔁 716 💬 128 📌 337
Post image

To the surprise of some officials in Kyiv, no one from the U.S. bothered to ask Ukraine to share its expertise in how to defend against drones before starting the offensive in Iran, Simon Shuster and Nancy A. Youssef report. theatln.tc/AFPCstm6

06.03.2026 01:15 👍 320 🔁 105 💬 26 📌 26

You’re now “far left” unless you falsely claim an election was stolen against my personalist authoritarian wanna-be party leader, says constitutional law scholar

06.03.2026 00:55 👍 5 🔁 2 💬 0 📌 0

It’s happening again

05.03.2026 22:07 👍 523 🔁 29 💬 39 📌 1

That’s quite a combo of perspectives on this, indeed

05.03.2026 23:01 👍 1 🔁 0 💬 1 📌 0

Iraq's first lady, Shanaz Ibrahim Ahmed, a political/humanitarian figure from a prominent (& very political) Sulimaniyah-rooted Kurdish family closely tied to the PUK, coming in hot with a free history lesson for people who think Iraqi Kurds might be unquestioningly game for more US bait-and-switch.

05.03.2026 21:04 👍 578 🔁 187 💬 11 📌 11